Which Escape Room Should You Choose? (NYC 2025 Guide)
Choosing the right escape room can be overwhelming—especially in New York City, where there are dozens of options. This guide breaks down difficulty levels, themes, group sizes, and recommendations so you can confidently choose the best escape room for your group.
If you’re searching for the best escape room NYC experience, this guide will help you compare private rooms, difficulty levels, and themes so you can choose the perfect adventure.
1. Choose Based on Difficulty Level
If this is your first escape room experience, we recommend choosing a beginner or medium-difficulty room. Advanced rooms are designed for experienced players who understand escape room logic and puzzle flow.
2. Choose Based on Theme & Atmosphere
Your theme sets the tone for your adventure. Escape Room Madness offers a cinematic range of rooms—mystery, sci-fi, thriller, investigation, and apocalyptic survival. Pick a theme that matches your group’s comfort level and interests.
3. Choose Based on Your Group Size
Each room at Escape Room Madness is designed for specific group sizes. Smaller groups (2–4 people) may enjoy intimate rooms like the Quarantine room, while larger groups (5–12 people) may prefer high-energy experiences like Nuclear Annihilation or The Perfect Crime. All of our experiences are fully private escape rooms, ensuring your group has the entire adventure to yourselves.
Recommended Escape Rooms Based on Your Group
✔ For Beginners
-
The Perfect Crime – Best for murder mystery
-
Exodus – kids-friendly
✔ For Couples
-
Masquerade – Story-driven and immersive heist
-
Quarantine – Private, intimate, and balanced
✔ For Friends & Small Groups
✔ For Experienced Players
-
Nuclear Annihilation – High challenge, fast-paced
-
Quarantine – Thriller-based, medium-hard difficulty
These beginner-friendly NYC escape rooms provide a balanced experience with clear puzzle flow and high engagement.
